How we review CBD products
thCBDx does not test products in a laboratory. Unless a review explicitly documents first-hand testing, it is a research-based editorial assessment of verifiable product facts, comparative value and cited public feedback.
Scoring protocol v2.0 • effective 14 August 2026
The published weighting
- Label and specification clarity
- 20%
- Comparative value
- 20%
- Strength choice
- 15%
- Format practicality
- 15%
- Ingredients and allergens
- 15%
- Portability
- 10%
- Packaging and disposal
- 5%
Evidence grade is separate from product score
What grades A–D mean
- A
- Strong exact-product record
- A current physical sample, documented protocol, original imagery, matching batch evidence and useful attributable exact-product feedback.
- B
- Substantial evidence
- Physical assessment or unusually strong exact-product documentation and feedback, with only a limited material gap.
- C
- Useful but incomplete
- A detailed current specification and traceable sources, but no physical sample, batch match or sufficient exact-product feedback.
- D
- Catalogue-level evidence
- Basic product and price facts are available, while important product-specific documentation or feedback remains missing.
Physical review protocol
A supplied sample never buys a score
- 1Log who supplied the product, its retail condition, receipt date, batch or lot details and whether it was provided free of charge.
- 2Photograph the sealed product, label, ingredients, warnings, batch details, packaging and any material compatibility or disposal instructions.
- 3Match available COAs and specifications to the exact product and batch. Supplier documents are labelled as supplier evidence, not independent laboratory work by thCBDx.
- 4Assess only observable, format-relevant qualities. We do not test medical outcomes, create personalised dosing advice or infer legal compliance from packaging alone.
- 5For vape products, no non-vaper is asked to start. Any sensory assessment must be performed by an existing adult vaper using compatible hardware and is reported as subjective.
- 6Give the supplier a route to correct factual errors or provide missing documents, without offering editorial approval, a guaranteed publication date or a minimum rating.
Brands can offer a sealed retail sample or product documentation through our evidence and sample intake form. Shipping details are shared privately only after acceptance.
Selection criteria
We list products from participating retailers when they have a public product page, published product data and are legal to sell in the UK.
Product data sources
Product details are sourced from the manufacturer's product page and printed label. We do not invent product specifications.
Price check process
Prices are checked periodically and shown with a 'last checked' date. Confirm the current price on the retailer's page before purchase.
Affiliate relationship
thCBDx earns commission on qualifying purchases made through our affiliate links. This does not change the price you pay.
Featured product ordering
Featured placement reflects editorial judgement about product breadth and clarity of information. Featured products are not paid placements.
Editorial assessment
Our published scores combine verified specifications, price and range comparisons, format practicality and recurring preference themes in public customer and independent reviewer feedback. We distinguish researched assessment from documented hands-on testing.
AI-assisted workflow
AI tools may assist with extracting structured product facts, comparing like-for-like products, identifying themes across cited material and preparing an initial draft. AI is not treated as a source. A human editor reviews the evidence, wording, disclosures and score before publication and remains responsible for the final page.
Scoring
Upgraded reviews use seven pre-defined weighted criteria: label and specification clarity (20%), comparative value (20%), strength choice (15%), format practicality (15%), ingredients and allergen transparency (15%), portability (10%), and packaging and disposal information (5%). Component scores are multiplied by their published weights and the result is rounded to the nearest half-point. The five-star graphic is the same rounded score divided by two; it is an editorial rating, not an aggregate of customer reviews. A score of 8 or more is score-qualified, but the Highly recommended badge is shown only when the evidence grade is also A or B.
Supplier fairness
A lack of first-hand testing lowers the evidence grade; it does not lower the product score. We deduct only for a product attribute or omission that is relevant to a reasonable buying decision and within the supplier's control. Products are compared with realistic peers in the same format and price position—not with an imaginary perfect product. Subjective preferences do not become universal faults, and suppliers may provide corrections or current documentation without purchasing or approving coverage.
Evidence scanner
Our scanner records the source, check date and a content fingerprint so changes can be audited. It counts product-specific feedback separately from retailer specifications and independent reviews. Source coverage and relevant feedback totals are shown on reviewed product pages. A higher volume does not automatically produce a higher score.
Customer and supplier feedback
We use product-specific feedback to identify repeated observations about flavour, texture, packaging, value and usability. Supplier-wide Trustpilot ratings may be displayed separately as merchant reputation but never determine an individual product score. Trustpilot data is accessed only through an authorised API or widget; we do not scrape the platform.
thCBDx reader feedback
Readers can submit first-party product feedback with optional retailer, month-used, batch and private verification details. Submissions require an attestation that the exact product was used, are rate-limited, checked by a human and never published automatically. Duplicate, promotional, abusive and medical-claim content is excluded. Self-attestation or an email address is not described as verified purchase.
Uncertainty and exclusions
A review receives limited, moderate or high evidence coverage according to the number and independence of usable sources and the size of its product-specific feedback sample. Health outcomes, unsupported medical claims, company-wide ratings, duplicated comments and feedback that cannot be tied to the exact product are excluded from product scoring.
Corrections
If we find or are told about an error, we correct it and add a dated correction note to the affected page.
Update schedule
Product data is reviewed at least every 90 days, or sooner where the retailer updates the product page.
Limitations
Prices, stock and formulations can change. We timestamp catalogue checks and direct readers to the retailer and product label for final confirmation.
Every scored review identifies its sources and explains the practical trade-offs behind the rating. Affiliate commission does not increase a product's score, and products are not promised positive coverage.